Monday, May 06, 2013

Did Legalization Make Abortion Less Deadly for Mothers?

The Gosnell trial has been bringing news of safe and legal abortion deaths to the forefront. With this attention, of course, comes the standard abortion-rights assertion that the bad old days of illegal abortion were worse.

In a way, they're right. There were far more abortion deaths, and maternal deaths in general, in the decades before legalization. They're just dead wrong in where they place credit for the spectacular 20th century fall in maternal mortality.

I bring you Maternal Death Rates in America in the 20th Century:

This is all maternal deaths, from abortion, miscarriages, ectopic pregnancies, complications of childbirth, and so forth. You can see that the 20th Century got off to a good start, improving maternal health, but that trend would later level off, and then reverse itself temporarily, before taking the downward trend that would continue for the rest of the century.

Let's look at it again, but this time I'll put a vertical line at Roe vs. Wade, so we can see the clear, unmistakable, undeniable, staggering and spectacular impact ready access to safe, legal abortion had on maternal mortality:

For those of you with a faulty sarcasm detector: Roe didn't even amount to a blip on the line.

For those of you who get your information from abortion lobby "fact sheets" this might come as a bit of a shock. You're accustomed to being told things like: "The legalization of induced abortion beginning in the 1960s contributed to an 89% decline in deaths from septic illegal abortions (15) during 1950-1973." (Courtesy, in this case, of the Centers for Disease Control -- for those of you who had any doubts as to their abortion-praising agenda.)

Let's look specifically at abortion mortality, to see the profound and clear and unmistakable impact of legalization. I marked vertical lines at 1970 (when New York and California became the first states to legalize abortion on demand) and 1973 (when Roe vs. Wade legalized abortion on demand nationwide).

If you're having a hard time spotting it, I'll zoom in a bit on abortion deaths since 1960. Note that I marked New York and California's legalization and Roe vs. Wade for you:

The things put forth by abortion advocacy organizations leave you with the impression that improvement in maternal health in general, and abortion mortality in particular, must be due to the ready availability of legal abortion. But if you look at maternal mortality, as we just did, and look at the legalization of abortion, as we just did, you can see that the dramatic and very laudable drop in maternal death in the 20th Century was achieved with no help whatsoever from the abortion lobby.

To whom is credit actually due, if it is not due to abortionists and abortion agitators? Let's look at some factors.

1. At the turn of the century, many maternal deaths were due to one sad factor: inadequate childhood nutrition. Inadequate calcium and vitamin D, especially for city children, caused rickets. This meant that women who developed rickets as children had small and/or malformed pelvises. This caused obstructed labor, a major contributor to high maternal mortality. (This problem persists in developing nations.) In the developed West, the problem of obstructed labor has been virtually eliminated, along with most nutritionally-related complications of pregnancy and childbirth. For this, we should thank:

  • Public health officials who pushed for vitamin D fortification and pasteurization of milk
  • Farmers who increased the supply of milk and produce
  • Agricultural officials who worked to improve the health of farm animals and to improve farm productivity.
  • Truck drivers and other transportation workers who brought the milk and produce from farm to city.
  • Inventors and entrepreneurs who made electricity and refrigeration cheap and widely available so that milk, meat, and produce would stay fresh.
  • Planners and workers who built the highway system and other elements of the transportation infrastructure to facilitate the transport of milk, and fresh meat and produce, from farm to city.
  • Inventors and entrepreneurs who created jobs and raised the standard of living so that families could afford milk and fresh produce for their children.
  • Grocers who made all of these products available to consumers.

    2. The biggest contributors to the reduction in septic deaths were the unglamorous enterprises of sanitation and hygiene. Less trash in the streets meant fewer rats and other vermin, fewer risks of disease. Running water, sewage treatment, and the widespread use of gas and electric stoves and water heaters made the basic healthy hygiene we take for granted available. For this, we should thank:
  • City planners who developed strategies for improving cleanliness of our urban areas.
  • Utility workers who keep our water running and hot.
  • Sanitation workers who expose themselves to the dangers of garbage-related diseases and in doing so, protect mothers and children.
  • Waste-management workers of all levels, who have eliminated the ages-old health hazards of, to put it daintily, "grey water."

    3. Of course, medical advances played their vital roles. We owe a tremendous debt of gratitude to:
  • Joseph Lister and others who pioneered antiseptic technique that reduced septic compilations and made C-sections practical.
  • J.Y.Simpson and other pioneers of anesthesia who made C-sections and other surgery practical.
  • Ignaz Philip Semmelweiss, whose career was left a shambles by his fight to eliminate childbed fever, and those who took his advice and began the practice of simple hand-washing, which we take for granted, in attending laboring and postpartum women.
  • Researchers and pharmaceutical companies that made antibiotics, anti-coagulants, and other vital medicines available.
  • Doctors, nurses, and technicians who developed new medical technologies and worked to make them widely available.
  • Biomedical companies and workers for making everything from sterile bandages to high-tech monitoring and surgical equipment readily available.
  • Housekeepers, orderlies, and other non-glamorous but vital workers who keep the medical environment clean and sanitary.

    When you reflect on the tremendous advances in public health, especially maternal and neonatal health, of the 20th Century, give credit where credit is due. Remember that it was our fellow citizens, working daily in often thankless and dangerous jobs, who wrought these miracles as much as doctors and medical pioneers. It is thanks to the trash collector, the worker out repairing the electrical lines in bitter weather, the farmer rising before dawn to milk the cows, the stock clerk stacking oranges in the supermarket, that we can so take it for granted that we will survive pregnancy and childbirth, and that our children will outlive their parents. The abortionists and their cheerleaders should learn a little humility.

  • 1 comment:

    Anonymous said...

    Great information; thank you. Unfortunately, I think the chart titles are misleading - these are not "abortion deaths" as much as they are "maternal deaths." Along that line, I'd love to see a graph that shows fetal deaths due to abortion over those same years.

    Again thank you - good information!